Have you ever heard, “Nonprofits can’t make a profit?” Think again. Let’s clear up one of the biggest myths about nonprofit organizations—and why it matters for your mission.

When people hear the word nonprofit, they often assume it means the organization isn’t supposed to make money or have a “profit”. But here’s the truth: nonprofits absolutely can—and should—generate a surplus or profit.

Let’s break down why that’s not only acceptable, but critical to your organization’s long-term success, and how this connects to your mission, transparency, and stewardship.

Nonprofits Should Bring in More Than They Spend

Nonprofits exist to serve a mission, not to generate wealth for owners or shareholders. But that doesn’t mean they should operate on a razor-thin margin or just break even.

In fact, generating more revenue than you spend is essential. A healthy surplus allows your organization to:

• Build reserves to handle unexpected expenses or emergencies
• Invest in infrastructure, technology, or staff to enhance your impact
• Navigate funding gaps and economic uncertainty without cutting critical programs

Without positive cash flow, you’re always one step away from crisis mode—and that can threaten the very mission you’re trying to serve.

The Key Difference: What Happens to the Surplus

So, what distinguishes a nonprofit from a for-profit business? It’s all about what happens to that extra money.

• For-profits distribute profits to owners or shareholders.
• Nonprofits reinvest any surplus back into the mission—whether it’s expanding services, upgrading equipment, or strengthening operations for the future.

In a nonprofit, every dollar of surplus serves to advance the cause—not to enrich private individuals. In short, individuals should not personally profit from a nonprofit.

The Tax Implications of Nonprofit Status

Nonprofit status—typically under IRS code 501(c)(3)—means your organization is exempt from federal income tax because your work provides public benefit. But that tax exemption comes with accountability.

Here’s what’s important to understand:

• Surpluses must be used to support your stated charitable purpose and not for the personal gain of any individual.
• Activities should align with your organization’s mission.
• Financial transparency is required, often through filings like the Form 990, which is a public document.

Ultimately, nonprofits have the privilege of tax-exempt status, but that privilege comes with the responsibility of integrity, transparency, and careful stewardship of funds.

Strengthening Your Financial Stewardship

The bottom line? Nonprofits need surplus to sustain and grow. But balancing financial health with mission impact, regulatory compliance, and donor trust can be complex.

That’s where strategic financial leadership makes all the difference. A fractional CFO can help your organization:

• Align budgets with your mission and outcomes
• Build healthy reserves without undermining program delivery
• Strengthen reporting and internal controls to protect your integrity

If you want your organization to thrive—not just survive—consider partnering with a financial expert like me, who can help you build a sustainable future while staying true to your mission.

Your mission deserves more than break-even “survival mode.”

To learn more about how we partner with nonprofits to help them thrive with more resources to do more good, click here.

If you found value in this post, subscribe to my blog and receive weekly wisdom for nonprofit leaders just like you. If you’re hungry for more, you can always browse our Youtube channel library for over 150 other videos related to nonprofit finance or you can begin the conversation by telling us about your nonprofit here. I look forward to serving you.